Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Animation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Animation. Show all posts

Monday, 18 May 2020

My Top 5 Christian Films (That Aren’t Really Christian Films)


“I know that lying down on the wet grass is not a normal thing to do … Truth is, uh, I’ve been even more strange than usual lately, haven’t I? It’s God. I have ten thousand engagements of state today, but I would prefer to spend the day getting a wet arse, studying dandelions and marvelling at bloody spiders’ webs … I think [God] found me. Do you have any idea how inconvenient that is, how idiotic it will sound? I’ve a political career glittering ahead of me, and in my heart I want spiders’ webs.”

Amazing Grace (2006)



1)     Amazing Grace (2006)



Amazing Grace isn’t a Christian film. It’s a historical biopic and a political drama.

 
A portrait of William Wilberforce by a German artist called Anton Hickel, apparently.

The film is set in the eighteenth century and follows the career of William Wilberforce and the progress of the abolitionist movement. It’s basically a story about a bunch of young radicals with a righteous cause trying to change the world against seemingly impossible odds; you know how it’s going to end, but that supplies half the fun of getting there. Please don’t be put off by the trailer,1 which you can immediately tell was made by Americans,2 and also behaves as if the whole film were nothing more than an origin story for John Newton’s famous hymn; in reality it’s far more than that. The story is great, the acting is great (the most well-known stars of the film include Michael Gambon as Charles Fox, Toby Jones as the Duke of Clarence, and a before-he-was-famous Benedict Cumberbatch as Pitt the Younger), the aesthetics are great (who doesn’t love a good period costume?3), and the scripting is just so on point: every line is both purposeful and pleasing. The portion I quoted above is quite good, of course, but my favourite line has to be when the Duke of Clarence, speaking in Parliament, describes revolution as a ‘pox’, and Wilberforce answers with, “I bow to my honourable friend’s superior knowledge and experience in all matters regarding the pox.”



2)     Les Miserables (2012)



Les Miserables isn’t a Christian film. It’s a somewhat dark and depressing sung-through musical.



I once came home from a really convicting Bible study in a really intense mood and found my housemates watching Les Mis. Having joined them, I suspect that I may have slightly weirded them out by periodically yelling at Javert for having such terrible theology. But of course, Javert having terrible theology is kind of the whole point. Jean Valjean, on the one hand, understands the gospel: he knows what it is to receive grace, to be blessed without having done anything at all to deserve it, and to live life differently as a result. Javert, on the other hand, cannot even begin to cope with the idea of receiving something he can’t pay the giver back for. His idea of justice has no room for mercy, and so he accepts no mercy himself.



It’s a really moving story (well, except for the love story between Marius and Cosette, which I have absolutely no time for): soaring hope and searing tragedy collapse in on top of each other, and through it all, Jean Valjean is a hero you can really root for. And then of course there’s the music. Do you hear the people sing? Yes, I do, and it’s frankly sensational.4



3)     The Prince of Egypt (1998)



The Prince of Egypt isn’t a Christian film. It’s an animated musical hailing from the Renaissance era of American animation5 and based, like so many others of its genre, on a well-known traditional story.



The animation is gorgeous: the splitting of the Red Sea is a particular highlight, though there are plenty of stunning visuals throughout the rest of the picture as well, and we also see DreamWorks developing its own unique style, distinct from Disney’s, which colours it as rather a shame that we didn’t get more two-dimensional work from the studio before the rise of CGI. And that soundtrack, gosh, it’s spine-chillingly good. ‘Deliver Us’ and ‘Playing with the Big Boys Now’ and ‘The Plagues’ – all brilliant.6 The only thing that ruins it slightly is how theologically clumsy – scratch that, downright wrong – the lyrics of ‘When You Believe’ are. Who knows what miracles you can achieve when you believe somehow you will? Ahem – I think it was God that did the miracles, O Fictionalised Miriam.



The film takes some artistic licence with the original version of the story, as you’d expect from a piece of this genre, so it’s very important not to let it muddy your knowledge of what actually happened: for instance, Moses was in fact raised by his own mother as his wet-nurse, and he doesn’t ever seem to have been ignorant of his Hebrew origins. Plus, the entire brotherly-conflict narrative on which the film hangs is completely invented.7 But I hasten to stress that that’s not a problem. I expect the creators of an essentially fictional film to be more interested in good filmmaking than in strict adherence to the source material. I want them to be more interested in good filmmaking than in strict adherence to the source material. Because, as obvious as it sounds, otherwise they’re probably not going to make a very good film, are they?



4)     Ben Hur (1959)



Ben Hur isn’t a Christian film. It’s an epic. A proper epic from the era of proper epics, when films came with an overture and an interval and a sense of genuine grandeur.

The 1959 film was not, of course, the novel’s first outing as a live-action adaptation. This is a poster for the 1899 Broadway production of the story.

The extremely popular book that the film was based on is called Ben Hur: A Tale of the Christ, but at least in this version of the film, Jesus is really only a background character. And you never see his face, which I really appreciated as a decision: first off, artistically, it’s more impactful, and second, I’m a bit of a puritan when it comes to the second commandment, and so anything that attempts to actually depict Jesus makes me uncomfortable to say the least.8 In Ben Hur, you don’t really see Jesus, you don’t really hear him, and you have to interpret what he’s like from how other people react to him, which I’d say is basically as good as you’re going to get in terms of plausible ways of portraying the ineffably excellent Lord of the universe in the limited and fallible medium of film.



But as I say, the film’s not even about him. It’s about Judah Ben Hur, who goes through an absolute rollercoaster of life experiences that make for some really dramatic (and properly epic) scenes, including a harrowing sea-battle, and of course the famous chariot race, made all the more compelling when you realise that it was all achieved without modern special effects: they are actually driving those chariots, and, fun fact (and sort of a spoiler, I’ll warn you), the bit where Judah gets thrown right over the front of his chariot was a total accident that some lucky cameraman managed to catch.9 It’s also about Judah’s childhood-best-friend-turned-sworn-arch-enemy Messala. And it’s about finding out that vengeance isn’t what you needed to make everything better after all.



There’s a nice hint at the gospel in the paralleling of the scene where Jesus gives Ben Hur a drink of water when he’s practically dying of thirst while being marched to work as a galley slave, and the one where Ben Hur tries to give Jesus a drink of water when he’s being marched to the cross, but is prevented. Jesus is the spring of living water, and he gives us life, and there’s no possibility of ever giving him something he needs in return.10 But as I say, it’s only a hint. You have to know the gospel already to find it.



5)     Luther (2003)



Luther isn’t a Christian film. It’s another historical biopic.



If you’re looking for a balanced and objective portrayal of Martin Luther, Luther isn’t the place to get it. The film turns him into an almost undiluted hero, and of course sweeps On the Jews and Their Lies and his other antisemitic work entirely under the carpet.11 But if you’re looking for a blooming good film, well, you’ve got one.12 Luther is a story about a man who starts a revolution almost accidentally, and then finds that revolution spiralling out of his control. It’s about how deep people will go in corruption and falsehood and abuse of the weak in order to hold onto their power, and it’s about how they can nonetheless never succeed in silencing the truth. It’s beautifully scripted and acted. And I suppose it does actually articulate the substance of the gospel once or twice. Perhaps it really is a Christian film after all.



To be fair, I never specified any criteria for what counts as a Christian film and what doesn’t. Maybe, when it comes down to it, I don’t believe there’s actually any such thing as a Christian film. The point of a film is to tell a story. Some films tell stories that align more closely with a Christian worldview than others. But if a film makes it its mission to privilege the perpetuation of a Christian message over the creation of a compelling piece of cinema, I’m not sure that makes it a Christian film. I think probably, as I also alluded to under The Prince of Egypt above, it just makes it a bad one.



The point of a film is to tell a story. It isn’t to tell the truth. The Prince of Egypt’s artistic licence, Luther’s whitewashing of its title character – they’d be crimes in a courtroom, but in cinema they’re just part and parcel of the process, because each film is telling a particular story, and in that story, there isn’t room for everything that’s true. If you want to communicate a message to someone – if there’s something important that you want her to know – you don’t make a film about it. You just tell her, plainly. You make a film, on the other hand, because you want to tell a story. There’ll be messages somewhere in there, sure – I stand by what I’ve previously argued, that all fiction inevitably encourages its audience to buy into a particular set of ideas13 – but they’ll be subtler. There’ll be different ways of reading the thing, different possible emphases. People will be able to draw out all sorts of headcanons and theories and wild implications. Just look at me ravaging the world of secular cinema for analogies by which to better understand God and the gospel.



And that’s the role that I think films can have in the Christian imagination. We can watch them, ‘read’ them, analyse them, critique them, map aspects of them onto the truth of the gospel and note the divergences, find those hints of the gospel and extrapolate them, and in doing so, develop new ways of reflecting on the hope that we have – and maybe new ways of communicating it to others. But the point is not that the motion picture in front of us is a ‘Christian film’, but that, as Christians, we take the gospel wherever we go. We take it into the cinema, and the theatre, and the library, and the virtual world; we carry it in every encounter, every conversation, every moment of private thought; and we don’t engage with anything without engaging the gospel too. The point is not that such-and-such is a ‘Christian film’; the point, adelphoi, is that you, or I, or whichever brother or sister of ours it is, is watching it as a Christian.14



Footnotes



1 You can watch it here, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q6Cv5P9H9qU, but I wouldn’t bother if I were you.



2 I hasten to reassure my American friends that I don’t at all mean to imply that all things made by Americans are bad; what I’m getting at is that there’s a particular American mode of making film trailers that basically treats the audience as if they’re stupid and won’t understand what’s happening if there’s any deviation from the expected format. By way of evidence, I submit to you the following Blimey Cow video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g--WPsnqoHA, and as a case-study, the British trailer for The Pirates! In an Adventure, with Scientists, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWOFLtsDvbw, as compared to the American one, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzddJ-yxaqY. You’ll spot that they also renamed the film The Pirates! Band of Misfits for the US market. It’s just depressing.



3 People who are into period costume are fun to follow on YouTube and Instagram. I have recently started following Zach Pinsent, Bernadette Banner, and Karolina Zebrowska. Here’s Ms. Zebrowska’s video ‘100 Years of Beauty – Poland’, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrEPujmWufU, which is literally one of my favourite things on the Internet.



4 Fancy a rewatch of the ‘One Day More’ scene? Of course you do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sv-BxH3SVS8.



5 The Disney Renaissance refers to the period between 1989 and 1999, when Disney went back to producing films based on well-known traditional stories, and did extraordinarily well out of it. I don’t think it’s any coincidence that when DreamWorks Animation came on the scene in 1994, they tried the same tack, and it’s for that reason that I don’t mind lumping their stuff together with Disney’s in a broader Renaissance of American animation.



6 This scene though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJleW4TCQM0. Chills.



7 Don’t take my word for it: check out the story for yourself: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=exodus+2&version=ESVUK.



8 You have J. I. Packer to thank for persuading me round to this view a few years ago in his excellent Knowing God: https://www.10ofthose.com/uk/products/1782/knowing-god.






10 That’s John 7 I’m alluding to there: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John+7&version=ESVUK. Or alternatively John 4, but John 7 seems to me to be less regularly taught, so I thought I’d send you there first.



11 I think Adam4d probably captures the sentiment best: https://adam4d.com/hang-with-martin-luther/. Mind you, I gather Luther was pretty antisemitic during his earlier career as well. Christian antisemitism, I tend to feel, is one of those things that’s kind of so inherently ludicrous – I mean, we literally worship a Jew, where is the logic here?! – that it would be laughable if it hadn’t proved itself so terrifyingly potent over the centuries.



12 You can actually get the whole thing on YouTube, so that’s nice: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hAACMptKD-c.



13 Check out ‘The Disorientating Nature of La La Land and Life’, under July 2018 in the box on the right, if you want to see me make that case.



14 And before I go, a tip of the hat to Scripts for helping me out with those Amazing Grace quotations: https://www.scripts.com/script.php?id=amazing_grace_2638&p=4.

Sunday, 10 May 2020

Man Hands on Misery to Man, or Azula and the Dominoes


“They f**k you up, your mum and dad.
They may not mean to, but they do.
They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were f**ked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another’s throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don’t have any kids yourself.”
Philip Larkin, ‘This Be The Verse’ (1971)

Well, you know how it is. Sometimes you open YouTube with the aim of amusing yourself for maybe ten or fifteen minutes in between doing other stuff, and you end up taking in an entire hour-long video essay devoted to scholarly psychological analysis of an animated fictional character. We’ve all done it, right?

The animated fictional character in question when this scenario befell me earlier this week was Azula, one of the foremost antagonists featured in Avatar: The Last Airbender, which I have now finished watching, and yes, it deserves the hype, so I do recommend that if you haven’t seen it already, you go and do so before plunging recklessly into the minefield of spoilers that is the rest of this post.1 As for the rest of you, be not afeared that I might be about to review that entire hour-long video essay in acute detail; I’ll confine my recollection of its contents to only the most salient aspects as regards my own concern in this post.2
 
A magnificent more realistic artistic interpretation of Azula, for which I owe thanks to the talented PkBlitz at newgrounds.com.
Azula, to remind you, is the daughter of the Fire Lord, and is notable for being prodigiously talented at firebending, extremely clever, an utter perfectionist, a master manipulator, power-hungry, sadistic, consistently ruthless, and altogether not somebody you want to be getting between you and your goals for two whole series of an animated drama. In his video essay, YouTuber Hello Future Me attributes many of Azula’s traits and behaviours to her experiences in childhood. In particular, her parents were noticeably rubbish at ‘co-parenting’, that is, raising their children according to one consistent framework of values upheld by both of them. While Fire Lord Ozai encouraged and rewarded the development of power, cunning, and loyalty, his wife Ursa preferred to nurture trust, empathy, and love. Because Azula was so good at firebending, and doesn’t seem to have naturally been very empathic, it was from her father that she received most of the positive feedback she was given as a child; and because kids respond to positive feedback, it was according to the values her father taught her that she came to define her success in life, her worth, even her moral adequacy. Hence the perfectionism and ruthlessness and so forth. Her brother Zuko, on the other hand – not nearly as talented, but a real little trooper who would consistently pick himself up and try again – was more likely to receive positive feedback from his mother, and so ended up internalising something of the value structure she was parenting according to. And, while Zuko also spends the best part of the serial being rather an unpleasant dude, you could tell pretty much all along that there was a redemption arc waiting in the wings for him. Sure enough, he ends the series, having defected to the good guys in time for the final battle, by being crowned Fire Lord and promising to work with the Avatar to build a future based on love and peace – a far cry from his father’s violent imperialistic expansion. Azula, on the other hand, ends it by having a mental breakdown and losing everything she’d ever hoped and striven for.

Hello Future Me concludes: “Azula’s story is a tragedy at heart. Her psychology is the last domino to fall in a long chain of familial abuse, flawed parenting, and emotional rejection.” A tragedy. It wasn’t Azula’s fault that she turned out the way she did; it was an inevitable result of the circumstances that befell her. She can’t be blamed for all the evil she did. She could never have turned out any other way.

This conclusion reminds me of an article I saw in the theatre programme for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.3 It was a friend’s programme I was reading (I’m always too much of a cheapskate to purchase one of my own), so I don’t have it at hand to consult, but the gist of the thing was a compare-and-contrast exercise between Harry and Voldemort. We all know that their similarities are played on through much of the canon: orphans raised by Muggles who eventually find the home they’d never had at Hogwarts, enough Slytherin tendencies for the Sorting Hat to at least suggest it, eventual fixation on magical means of mastering death (Hallows versus Horcruxes). So why does Harry end up our hero and Voldemort his utterly maleficent foe? According to the author of the article, the one vital factor was that first short year of Harry’s life where he was loved and cared for by his parents before they were killed. Voldemort, having been dumped at an orphanage pretty much as soon as he entered the world, never had that. And so the dominoes fell.
 
Kind of interesting that dominoes have become a byword for something that they’re not even actually for if you think about it.
I didn’t much like this way of looking at things when I read it in my borrowed theatre programme, and I still don’t much like it now. Like, that’s it? If you had a messed-up childhood then you’re going to end up being a terrible person and there’s no way round it? Nobody can ever be held accountable for his behaviour, because it’s really all the fault of those who raised him – who probably had messed-up childhoods of their own, and so on and so on back to the beginning of everything? There’s no hope of any better ending to the story? Philip Larkin was right?4

Well, let me be generous: maybe the author of the …Cursed Child article just didn’t have enough space to nuance her position properly in her allocated page of the programme. Hello Future Me’s hour of psychoanalysis, on the other hand, gives us a bit more to work with. Consider Zuko again. Although his mother’s positive feedback – as much of it as he got before she mysteriously disappeared5 – did foster in him more of an inclination towards her values than Azula ever had, when we meet him, he’s still very much conducting himself under the premise that his father’s values are the right ones. Specifically, he’s single-mindedly devoting himself to tracking down and capturing the Avatar, because the Fire Lord has decreed that that’s the only way he can regain his honour. He really, really wants his honour back – that state of affairs is so heavily stressed that it begins to caricaturise itself – and the fact that he thinks it’s worth so much proves his acceptance and internalisation of his father’s value-system. What really drags Zuko over to the side of righteousness isn’t how his mother parented him all those years ago; based on that alone, a redemption arc of the type the writers give him seems almost inconceivable. What really drags Zuko over to the side of righteousness is what Hello Future Me calls his ‘rescue parent’ – still my favourite Last Airbender character, Uncle Iroh.

Zuko’s Uncle Iroh, assigned to accompany him on his search for the Avatar after an embarrassing defeat at the Earth Kingdom capital of Ba Sing Se nudged him into retirement from leading Fire Nation armies, loves him. Properly loves him. He sticks with him through thick and thin, he takes care of him, he puts his needs first, he defends him, he mentors him, and he continually encourages him to do what’s right rather than what his father expects of him. He tells him that his honour isn’t the Fire Lord’s to give or take from him. He keeps on putting forward those values of trust and empathy and love, and it takes a long time and several false starts, but eventually, Zuko decides that it’s those values he wants to live by. Don’t get me started, though, on how stupendously adorable and uplifting and heart-meltingly Prodigal-Son-esque the whole plotline is, because boy will I gush about it.

Zuko’s trajectory from messed-up childhood to messed-up approach to life would surely have been only slightly different to Azula’s, except that Uncle Iroh stuck his hand between the dominoes before they fell. Hope for a better ending after all? Well, yes, but only up to a point, because where was Azula’s Uncle Iroh? Where was her ‘rescue parent’? “In this sense,” says Hello Future Me, “it was Azula who was left behind, who wasn’t rescued, who wasn’t nurtured, who wasn’t wanted in the same way that Zuko was.” And that’s why he gets a redemption arc and she gets a tragedy. It’s still a pretty bleak picture: no longer, if you had a messed-up childhood you’re doomed to be a terrible person; but still, if you had a messed-up childhood and nobody steps in to rescue-parent you, you’re doomed to be a terrible person. Better, but not great.
 
Hearty thanks to TheIcarusCrisis at newgrounds.com for this very skilled and charming rendering of Uncle Iroh enjoying a cup of tea, as he so frequently is.
Still, if we’re talking about rescue parents – isn’t there someone who rather springs to mind who can step in to rescue-parent anyone?

If I’m allowed to have a favourite doctrine, I think the doctrine of adoption might just be it. “But when the completion of the time came,” writes Paul to the Galatians, “God sent out his son, born of woman, born under law, so that he might purchase those under law; so that we might receive adoption as sons. And because you guys are sons, God sent out the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying: Abba, Father! So you are no longer a slave but a son; and if a son, also an heir through God.”6 You might not have picked up, incidentally, that he switches from a second-person plural to a second-person singular for that last sentence – not merely, you guys, collectively, are sons, but each of you, specifically, is a son and heir of God. This truth is for you as an individual, O Redeemed and Adopted Reader. Whatever messed-up stuff you may have been through that you thought had had an irreparable effect on who you are, you’re not a slave to it. You’ve been purchased for adoption. God has stepped in as your rescue parent.

And even if, by contrast, you had an absolutely stellar childhood, you needed him to step in like that. The thing is, Philip Larkin sort of was right; our parents, however good a job they do, do fill us with the faults they have, just by default, because the whole human bloodline, descended from Adam, is governed by sin. We inherit the sinful nature from our parents, and it dooms us to be terrible people. The dominoes fall. But for God our rescue parent, we are destined, as surely as Azula, to end up losing everything at the end of the serial we call the present age. (It keeps getting renewed for new series, you’ll have noticed, and the current one has certainly featured some unexpected twists.) But God loves you so much, brother or sister of mine, that before even the very first episode of the serial aired, he had already written your redemption arc.

God your heavenly Father loves you – properly loves you: “See what kind of love the Father has given us,” writes John in 1 John 3, “so that we might be called children of God; and we are.” He sticks with you through thick and thin: “Everything that the Father gives me shall come to me,” says Jesus in John 6, “and the one who comes to me I will certainly not throw out.” He takes care of you: “If, therefore,” says Jesus in Matthew 7, “you guys, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in the heavens give good things to those who ask him!” He puts your needs first: “Our Lord Jesus Christ … gave himself for our sins,” writes Paul in Galatians 1, “so as to deliver us out of the present age of evil, according to the will of our God and Father.” He defends you: “My Father who has given [my sheep] to me is greater than everything,” says Jesus in John 10, “and no one can snatch out of my Father’s hand.” He mentors you: “[I pray] that the God of our Lord Jesus Christ,” writes Paul in Ephesians 1, “the Father of glory, may give you guys a spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of him.” And he continually encourages to do what’s right rather than what the world, whatever flesh-bound value-system you may have internalised over the years, expects of you. This morning I was reading 1 John 2: “Do not love the world, nor the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him, because everything in the world, the desire of the flesh and the desire of the eyes and the false pretension of life, is not from the Father, but is from the world, and the world is passing away, and its desire too, but the one who does the will of God remains forever.”

God your Father tells you that your honour – the validity and worth and dignity of you as a person and your existence in the world – isn’t anyone’s to give or take from you except his, and he has pronounced you (yes, you, brother or sister, you as an individual) his son and heir, and nothing you do or fail to do could ever change that. We’re all messed up – and some have been through more messed-up stuff than others – but there is nobody that God can’t rescue-parent off that trajectory and into eternal life, because the whole of our purchase for adoption is achieved by Jesus laying down his life for our sins, and not by anything pertaining to who we were before, what we’ve done, or what other people have done to us.

You’re a son of God. You’re not a slave to anything else. Man may hand on misery to man, but, by the will of God, for you, the dominoes fall no longer.

Footnotes

1 All episodes are available on Netflix: https://www.netflix.com/title/70142405.

2 Although please do check the whole thing out for yourself if you fancy it; as you’ll gather from the fact that I finished it, it’s pretty blooming interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4544ZUr_gA.

3 Obviously I’m not going to give you the link for tickets at the moment. But you can still enjoy Imogen Heap’s gorgeous soundtrack: https://www.harrypottertheplay.com/uk/music/.

4 ‘This Be the Verse’ is pretty high up in terms of my favourite Philip Larkin poems I’ve read. I also like ‘Aubade’ (depressing but incisive) and ‘Dockery and Son’ (less depressing, if still pretty existential-crisis-y, and really beautifully put together): https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poets/philip-larkin#tab-poems.

5 Apparently the mystery of her disappearance is solved in one of the comic-book trilogies that pick up the story where the television serial left it. The first trilogy is called ‘The Promise’, https://www.waterstones.com/book/avatar-the-last-airbender-the-promise-library-edition/gene-luen-yang/9781616550745, and in completely unrelated news, I have a birthday coming up next month.

6 That’s from the fourth chapter of the letter; have the ESV, though this week I did actually bother to write my own translations of the passages I quoted: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=gal+4&version=ESVUK. Also, this being my last footnote, since I didn’t manage to clarify this in the main body, I’d like to leave a little note to the effect that I also don’t think that having a messed-up childhood  irreparably dooms someone to end up being a terrible person even by the world’s standards. But that wasn’t my point here, and you know, given that God ordains everything anyway...