Search This Blog

Sunday 5 February 2017

Thoughts on Doctor Strange 3: Sometimes the Bad Guys Are Right

“Humanity longs for the eternal.”
Doctor Strange (2016)

Things bad guys are typically after: number one, power; number two, revenge; or number three, immortality.
 
The sand only ever runs down...
Bad guys are obsessed with living forever. They’re always chasing after mystical relics or dabbling in forbidden branches of magic or doing dodgy deals with otherworldly powers in order that they might do so. As soon as anyone in fiction expresses a desire to live forever, I the reader or viewer immediately have my guard up: craving immortality is a key symptom of villainhood. The type is manifest in Voldemort and in Mother Gothel from Tangled and in the creepy old people from the Declaration trilogy1 and in Blackbeard from Pan and in Queen Ravenna from Snow White and the Huntsman and in Lord Cob from Studio Ghibli’s Tales from Earthsea and in a whole Pandorica-party of Doctor Who villains (John Lumic, Richard Lazarus, the Family of Blood)2 – and Kaecilius,3 the major antagonist of Doctor Strange, is another shining example.

The scheme for obtaining immortality that Kaecilius has devised consists of allowing a monstrous supernatural entity called Dormammu, who exists outside time in a chunk of multiverse known as the Dark Dimension, to absorb the world into his timeless self, hence granting all humanity a perpetual existence unhindered by the onward march of days and years towards inevitable death. Considering that Dormammu is an amoral being of limitless power and with an appetite for destruction that can never be satisfied, inviting him (or ‘it’?) to a let’s-destroy-the-world party isn’t exactly the best plan ever, and so our hero Doctor Stephen Strange, by now reasonably well practised in drawing on the power of the multiverse to bend reality, teleport, and hit people really hard, sets out to stop him from fulfilling it. Amidst the ensuing epic and amusing fight scenes, Kaecilius at one point, in good old-fashioned villain style, embarks upon a monologue about his motivations and plan with a view to persuading Stephen to join his side:

You are a doctor. A scientist. You understand the laws of nature. All things age. All things die. In the end, our sun burns out, our universe grows cold and perishes. But the Dark Dimension, it’s a place beyond time … This world doesn’t have to die, Doctor. This world can take its rightful place among so many others, as part of the One. The great and beautiful One. And we can all live forever … Life. Eternal life. People think in terms of good and evil, but really, time is the true enemy of us all. Time kills everything. [The people I killed were] tiny, momentary specks within an indifferent universe … you see what we’re doing? The world is not what it ought to be. Humanity longs for the eternal, for a world beyond time, because time is what enslaves us. Time is an insult. Death is an insult. Doctor, we don’t seek to rule this world. We seek to save it.4

All right, I know he’s the bad guy and all, but isn’t there something in what Kaecilius is saying here? It’s a simple matter of ever-increasing entropy, a product of sheer irresistible weight of probability, that, in the world as we know it, everything decays and dies. Order gives way to chaos and the relentless march of time does away with everything in the end. And we don’t like it. We can pour our every effort into postponing the inescapable end of the things we hold dear for as long as possible, and we can put on a brave face and make noble speeches about the virtue in graciously accepting the inevitable and the value of remembering the lost, and we can even go so far as to claim that good things would be unappreciable and meaningless if they never ended, but we still don’t like it. The comforts with which we shield ourselves from the horror of the all-consuming abyss that is eternity are very small comforts indeed.

Dark sentiments, I know, but I don’t think they’re untrue. All good things must come to an end, as the saying goes, and it hurts, and it’s deeply saddening, and it’s extremely scary. It’s really no wonder that someone dissatisfied with the meagre relief offered by limp platitudes should alight on a solution as eminently ill-judged as Kaecilius’.

But fictional immortality always comes at a cost. Extra life has to be pilfered from other sources. Innocents – tiny, momentary specks in an indifferent universe – have to die. The life of the villain is rendered prolonged, certainly, but also fragile, inhuman, not really even life at all. So Voldemort had to commit a murder for every horcrux and essentially destroyed his own humanity in the process; Queen Ravenna relied on a constant supply of attractive young women whom she could magically age to renew her own youthh; Lord Cob’s striving to open the door between life and death upset the entire balance of the natural universe; and likewise, in Kaecilius’ case, he eventually got everything he ever wanted – eternal life as part of the One – but, as Dr Strange put it, he wasn’t going to like it. Less eternal life, more unending destruction. More eternal death, really.

It’s the cost that makes the seeking of everlasting life so villainous an endeavour, not the longing that prompts its being paid. It’s not just villains that crave immortality: we all hate death and the inevitable ending of everything; we all long for the eternal. What if we could access a sustainable source?

Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life. He does not come into judgement, but has passed from death to life. Truly, truly, I say to you, an hour is coming, and is now here, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live. For as the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself.5 – John 5:24-26

When Jesus promises eternal life to those who believe in him, he is not promising the kind of eternal life that all those fictional villains were chasing. There is no trade-off here, no cost, no illegitimate siphoning off of life from other sources or reducing it to an insipid existence that hardly even qualifies as genuine life. Jesus has life in himself, just as his Father has. His life isn’t dependent on anyone or anything else; it has its origins in his own self. His very nature begets it. He is the sustainable source of life that we need – and he gives eternal life freely to whomever hears what he says and believes it.

It wasn’t because Kaecilius wanted to live forever that he was the bad guy; it was because he was prepared to trample on other people as if they were mere specks, to abandon any notion of good or evil, in order to do so. He might have thought he was seeking to save the world, but he would have ended up destroying it if Dr Strange hadn’t stopped him.

Guess who it is that really saved the world?

Kaecilius was right: the world is not what it ought to be. Humanity longs for the eternal. But he was looking for it in the wrong place. Longing for the eternal is not a villainous tendency to be determinedly suppressed: it is a symptom of the fact that we were made for the eternal – and in Jesus, we can find it. Jesus has life in himself; if we are in him, we share in that life; and in the world to come, all things will be good, and none of them will age, or end, or die, ever again. Eternal life.

Footnotes



1 I talked about The Declaration in ‘Principles of Immortality’, under ‘2016’, then ‘March’ in the box on the right.



2 That lot was pretty much off the top of my head; some kind human has compiled a list of many, many more villains who fit the profile: http://villains.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Immortality_Seeker?page=32.



3 The name makes me laugh because it’s basically that of Caecilius, the main character in the first book of the Cambridge Latin Course. The following basically illustrates the way I initially learned Latin at school, except that our set was only a classroom, and we wore the costumes over our school uniform, and we definitely didn’t learn our lines: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QfxmE8nEyaU.



4 Many thanks to whichever thoughtful individual uploaded a transcript of the whole film’s dialogue to the following web address: http://transcripts.wikia.com/wiki/Doctor_Strange.



5 Whole chapter: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John+5&version=ESVUK. Lots of cool stuff going on here. And a good place to point people who suggest that Jesus never actually claimed to be God.

No comments:

Post a Comment