Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Conversations with myself. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conversations with myself. Show all posts

Sunday, 16 June 2019

Conversations with my Internal Nihilist, or A Mandate for Continued Existence


“Really, stop crying. You’ve got a lot to look forward to, you know: a normal human life on earth, mortgage repayments, the nine to five, a persistent nagging sense of spiritual emptiness. Save the tears for later, boyo.”
Doctor Who S6 E12, ‘Closing Time’ (2011)

Her:      Morning.

Me:      What are you doing here?

Her:      Well, I took a look at your schedule for the past little while, as I do, you know, and it seems you and I haven’t hung out in a little while. You’ve been spending far too much time enjoying the sensations of the present moment and far too little looking at the bleak, blank meaninglessness underneath them. So here I am to fix that. How about an hour or two of staring into the void?
 
Creates some sort of impression of voidishness, even if it can hardly be called an actual void. Thanks to Stuart Miles at freedigitalphotos.net.
Me:      Actually, you’re all right. I have other things to be getting on with.

Her:      Yeah, but do you, though? I mean, you might have other tasks that you’ve set for yourself, but is there really any point to any of them? Is completing them really going to do any good in the world, you being what you are? And, perhaps more to the point, are you really going to be able to concentrate on any of them now that I’ve started this conversation?

Me:      You just had to ask that last question, didn’t you? Fine, then, let’s go void-staring.

Her:      Yay!

Me:      But this time my readers are coming too. Any of them who fancy the trip, I mean.

Her:      Ooh, are you sure you want to do that? You know the kinds of places our conversations tend to go; I wouldn’t want to bring guests into that part of the house. Aren’t you concerned that people might start to worry about you?

Me:      Hardly. Everyone knows that I’m just about the most mentally stable person one could ever hope to meet. In fact, I’m so relentlessly fine and crisis-less that it’s actually kind of hilarious. So I’ll just slot in a little disclaimer here to the effect that when I go void-staring with you, our conversations are extremely theoretical and removed. They don’t carry any impetus towards practical action, or hold me hostage without my consent, or even have any prime influence on how I think, because I already know that I don’t find your way of looking at things compelling; all I’m doing by having the conversation is sweeping the paths that lead to that conclusion. It’s like those physics questions where the exam paper has already given you the correct answer, and all you have to do is set out the series of calculations by which you reach it. Show your working, and so prove with double certainty that the answer is right.

Her:      I wouldn’t be so cocky if I were you. The void is looking really existentially empty today. Take a look.

Me:      Oh boy. I hate this bit.

Her:      You see? All these things you claim you ought to be getting on with – what’s really the point of any of it? What does any of it achieve that’s actually worth something? Do you suppose the world would be any the worse if you were to vanish from it right now? or better yet, if you were never to have been born at all, and every deed of your sinful little life were to be unravelled from existence? Would that not be a mercy on the rest of creation, that it would be spared having to put up with all your wicked selfishness?

Me:      Apparently God the supremely merciful didn’t think so.

Her:      I’m not surprised you brought him up. But do you truly dare to imagine that he’s glorified in you, chief of sinners you, in your constant failure, your constantly loving the world more than him or neighbour? Do you dare to imagine that you ever do anything that isn’t irretrievably tainted by the evil impulses of your flesh? You’ve caught glimpses of your own heart, just glimpses, and were you not left breathless that something so vile, so bestially self-seeking, should ever have been allowed to exist in the first place? And what excuse have you, particularly given that you live in wealth and comfort and privilege and are probably literally the most fortunate person alive, what excuse have you for living as if without the proper gratitude to him who is your Lord and your Creator and the Redeemer of your soul from Gehenna?1

Me:      I have no excuse; I plead –

Her:      You plead the blood of Christ, I suppose? What a terribly handy get-out-of-jail-free card. Your spirit sits sinless in the heavenlies and cringes at every way in which you in the flesh fail to honour Christ as Lord, and won’t it be simply marvellous when the perishable is done away with and that spiritual version of you is all that remains, and doesn’t the very thought fill you with a profound and desperate longing – but a longing is all it is, because that’s not yours yet, is it? In fact, it’s blooming hard to begin to get your mind round the notion that it will ever be yours, seeing as it sits so far from anything you’ve ever actually experienced. And in the meantime, while your every thought and word and deed is still steeped in sin, what good are you to anyone? What benefit do you offer anyone? What loss would it be to anyone – or not rather a gain! – if you were simply to stop existing?

Me:      So now you’re, what, trying to get me to seek validation from people, but with the precondition that nothing anyone could say will convince you that I’m actually worth something? What is this, some sort of variant on impostor syndrome that swaps academic achievement for social and moral?2 That’s rather a dangerous line of argument for you to take, given that I pretty much showed impostor syndrome the door probably a couple of years ago now.

Her:      It’s no use pretending you’re still all cool and unruffled. I saw my words hit their mark.

Me:      Maybe so, but a hit doesn’t necessarily entail damage.

Her:      Oh, shut up, as if I’m buying that. I know I get under your skin. I’ve had you crying before, haven’t I? I’ve had you on your knees asking your precious Saviour with tentative earnestness why he lets you carry on living when nothing you do is ever truly good.

Me:      Hey, everyone has bad days. It’s just that those bad days lead to a slightly different set of questions if you know Jesus than if you don’t.

Her:      And one of those questions is, wouldn’t the world be better off without you pootling about in it being all sinful and stuff?

Me:      Dude, this conversation has been way too dark for way too long. Frankly, I am super bored. I’ve a good mind to just start ignoring you and get on with my day.

Her:      I won’t really go away until you answer the question, though.

Me:      Fine, then. I’ll answer the question. To kick off, you’ve presumably spotted that I am in fact currently still alive, and, given that God’s sovereign and all, that must mean he wants me alive. And since he is supremely wise and has engineered all of creation for the display of his glory, that must mean that me continuing to be alive, even, yes, continuing to be alive in flesh and sinfulness and imperfection, somehow glorifies him.

Her:      Your logic there might be sound, but it’s awfully thin to stand on.

Me:      I haven’t finished showing my working yet. Let’s entertain the opposite scenario. Suppose God were to bring about our full spiritual resurrection the moment we were born again, zap us bodily up to his presence in heaven the split second we turned from our idols and placed our trust in Christ. I mean, there wouldn’t be very much trusting Christ to witness before faith turned into sight, would there? How would God demonstrate his faithfulness to persist with us in patience our whole lives long? How would he demonstrate his justice in rewarding those who persevere in faith through suffering? How would he demonstrate the extent of his grace, sufficient for every stumble, if there was never any chance to stumble at all? and conversely, how would he demonstrate the extent of his power to radically sanctify people still living in the depths of enemy territory so that they stumble less and less often? How could he make even the worst things work together for the good of his people if, the moment they become his people, there are no more worst things any more? How could he grant his Church the privilege of building herself up in love if she’s never built together in the first place? How could his mercies be new every morning if there are no more mornings for them to be new in?
 
New every morning. Someone got up early to take this one.
Her:      Are you done yet?

Me:      Please. I could do this all day.

Her:      I thought you had other things to be getting on with. Speaking of which, where exactly do those mundane little tasks fit into this grand, inspiring picture you’re painting? The only point you’re able to ascribe to anything is the glorification of God, so anything you spend your time on that isn’t directly geared towards that is still totally worthless. And given how rubbish you are at obeying your professed Master, I can still make a very compelling case that you’re doing more harm than good.

Me:      You’re not listening. God is so mind-blowingly brilliant that he glorifies himself in my rebellion as much as in my obedience, in my defeats as much as in my triumphs. I mean, I’d very much rather be obedient, because God is mind-blowingly brilliant and all his ways are perfect and his instruction is the very measure of all that’s good and right, but God’ll have his glory either way. If I do rightly, he’s glorified because he’s the one who makes me capable of that; if I do wrongly, he’s glorified because his love and grace and mercy in carrying out the deserved punishment for all my wrongdoing on Jesus in my stead, so that I might be forgiven it, go light-years beyond any stretch of the human imagination.

Her:      You’re trying to claim that every single thing you ever do glorifies God?

Me:      Mate, I glorify God merely by existing. I glorify him merely by existing as his redeemed and adopted child, and that’ll be the case whatever I do, because, newsflash, I made literally no contribution whatsoever to its being brought about: it’s a gift of grace, so that no one might boast.3 In fact, you know what you are, at the end of the day?

Her:      Pray enlighten me.

Me:      You’re just another claim that salvation is by works, dressed up a bit differently to usual. You justify the notion that the world would get alone just fine without me, thank you very much, by suggesting that my good works are insufficient to earn me the right to exist. Well, duh! My good works are insufficient to earn me literally anything! Is that supposed to be some kind of news or something? My right to exist is not earnt. Rather, my responsibility to exist is freely and graciously given.

Her:      Responsibility?

Me:      So you are listening. Yes, responsibility, or duty, or if a right, then in the sense of a privilege. If God has caused me to exist for the sake of his glory, then for the sake of his glory, it’s my duty and my privilege to continue to exist.

Her:      Even if everything you’re doing feels pointless. Even if you’re convinced you’re doing more harm than good with every breath you take.

Me:      Hey, if the fact that I was dead in my sins didn’t stop God from glorifying himself through me, why should anything else threaten to? I have to say, you’re really clutching at straws now.

Her:      All right, fine, I give in. You are too blooming good at winning these arguments.

Me:      I’m just lucky you’re as pathetic as you are, really. You go down without too much of a fight. Sure, you’ve had me crying and asking God stupid questions, but you forget that crying and asking God stupid questions is something I tend to do fairly regularly and without a great deal of prompting. It’s all just part of showing my working.

Her:      Wow. I matter so little to you.

Me:      It’s true, you do. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that everything you do is pointless, and the world would be a better place if you were to vanish from it. But funnily enough, God has brought glory for himself even out of our little trip to the void, in my being moved to doxologise even if in nothing else. How’s that for mind-blowingly brilliant?

Footnotes

1 I’ve decided that the word ‘hell’ is confusing and am therefore trying not to use it. I’ll probably blog about that issue at some point, but for the moment, suffice it to say that Gehenna refers to everlasting fiery post-death punishment to which those who don’t obey God are sentenced. Or feel free to form your own conclusion from how the term is used: https://www.stepbible.org/?q=version=ESV|version=SBLG|strong=G1067&options=VHNUG.

2 Impostor syndrome is another thing I’m vaguely intending to blog about at some point, but again, for the moment, here’s the Wikipedia page to give you an introduction if you’re not familiar with the term: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impostor_syndrome.

3 There are a whole lot of scriptural allusions in this post, but this is probably the most explicit, from Ephesians 2: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Ephesians+2&version=ESVUK. I’ll leave you to hunt the rest down for yourself.

Saturday, 26 May 2018

More Conversations with my Internal Hopeless Romantic


Shannon:         Well, are you guys going to the dance this weekend, or do you still not have a boyfriend?
Natalie:             Er, Mal’s never had a boyfriend, because boys aren’t very attracted to her –
Mallory:           Sing it!
Natalie:             – physically or personality-wise!
Mallory:           Oh yeah, I’m plain and dull, Shannon, deal with it!
Studio C, ‘Mean Girls’ (2014)1
This is a suitably romantic picture, right?
Her:     Hey, um, listen – I’ve been thinking about that last conversation of ours…

Me:      Yeah, me too, actually.

Her:     Really? Wow. Shall we slot in a suggestion here that your readers might like to go and have a scan of that one for context before they proceed any further with this one? Because otherwise, this one isn’t going to make any sense at all.2

Me:      You just did.

Her:     So I did. Well, back to the matter at hand, then, I’ve been thinking about that last conversation of ours, and I’ve been thinking – do you really hate me that much?

Me:      Um –

Her:     Because, you know, you’re allowed and all; heck, you’re entitled to hold whichever opinions you please about the little facets of personality and thinking that hang out in your brain; you’re the boss, at the end of the day, however we might cause trouble and make it blooming difficult for you to act like it; but honey, some of what you said was really harsh.

Me:      Um, yeah –

Her:     And I get that you have to be that harsh with those of us hanging about up here who are relentlessly, irredeemably given over to causing you to walk according to the flesh instead of the spirit,3 but I hadn’t realised that you put me in that category. I knew you thought I was annoying and all, but I also thought you knew that I really do want the best for you.

Me:      Um, yeah, I –

Her:     Because I’m not inherently bad. It’s not a sin to want a romantic relationship. That sort of thinking was the mistake of early Christian ascetics who spurned anything vaguely resembling a material pleasure in the name of achieving a purer sort of spirituality – and that’s not a Biblical idea; it’s a Neoplatonist one draped with a veneer of Christian-ness.4 The flesh/spirit divide isn’t about immaterial stuff being inherently better than material stuff; on the contrary, material stuff is good and to be received with thanksgiving.5

Me:      Um, yeah, I know, honey.

Her:     You what?

Me:      I know. I’ve also been thinking about that last conversation of ours, and I’ve also been thinking that I was a bit harsh. I was a bit … reactionary. I made a good point, but I made it with excessive vehemence. I don’t really hate you that much.

Her:     Really? I’m so pleased to hear that, honey. I assume this means you’ll be taking my suggestions a bit more seriously from now on?

Me:      Ah. Well, let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

Her:     How many times do I have to tell you, the fact remains, if you want a romantic relationship, you’re going to have to form an attraction to somebody, and because you’re naturally completely rubbish at that, you’re going to need my help in order to –

Me:      Whoa, whoa. Backpedal a bit. Why, pray tell, is forming an attraction to somebody an automatic prerequisite for having a romantic relationship?

Her:     Well, it – it just is. What are you suggesting, that you’d be prepared to marry someone you had literally no chemistry with? That sounds like a recipe for disaster.

Me:      But for most of human history, in most human cultures, it’s been perfectly normal to marry people for reasons other than being uncontrollably head-over-heels in love with them. It’s been perfectly normal to look for a potential match within your limited social circle, and pick one you think would be a decent sort of human being to spend the rest of your life with – probably relying to a large extent on the suggestions of your parents, incidentally.

Her:     Oh, honey, shut up. Arranged marriage? Seriously?6

Me:      I’m just pointing out that your idea that substantial romantic attraction must necessarily precede any initiation of a romantic relationship is not a universal one. And even if it’s pretty pervasive in our society in terms of the stories we tell, it isn’t pervasively practised in real life. How is being introduced to someone with a view to considering whether you might like to marry him or her, really that different to, say, being set up, or even using a dating app?

Her:     But –

Me:      And, just to put some icing on that cake, marrying someone for a reason other than having fallen head-over-heels with that person is also very Biblical. That chapter I quoted at length last time to prove that singleness is the ideal also says the following: “because of the temptation to sexual immorality, each man should have his own wife and each woman her own husband.”7 It doesn’t sound terribly glamorous, but ‘because of the temptation to sexual immorality’ is actually a perfectly good, Biblical reason to seek a spouse. And let’s be real here, you live in my head; you know that that’s a reason that applies to me as much as most people.
 
Some very skilful icing on a rather appropriate cake.
Her:     But – I mean –

Me:      And finally, consider this: if it’s truly your ambition to get me into a romantic relationship, wouldn’t it make your life easier to have that prerequisite of substantial romantic attraction removed? You spend all your time trying to get past that obstacle, and I don’t make it easy for you; suppose you could bypass it altogether.

Her:     But – I mean – if we were to bypass it, and skip straight to trying to form a romantic relationship without cultivating the attraction first – what would that actually look like, in practical terms? How would you go about it? What would you do?

Me:      Well, I don’t know, do I? I don’t deal with that sort of thing. I thought that was your job.

Her:     Oh. Um, yes, well, I suppose it is sort of my remit, really – nobody else up here seems to have any ideas, at any rate – but – but, honestly, honey, I don’t actually know either.

Me:      Huh. I suspected as much.

Her:     See, if you could just cultivate an actual romantic attraction for someone, I’d know what to do…

Me:      Of course you would. Confessing romantic feelings is easy. Well, it’s not easy, but it’s at least straightforward. The course of action to take is obvious. I don’t need your help to figure that one out.

Her:     So here we are again. You have no need of me. You have no desire to ever pay me any attention. Turns out you do hate me that much after all.

Me:      Nah, I don’t. I agree with what you said about yourself: you’re not inherently bad. It’s not a sin to want a romantic relationship. Nor is it a sin – and I think this is a key thing that needs tempering or nuancing about what I said last time – to take actions designed to help you get one.

Her:     Well, that’s obvious. Nobody would ever end up in a romantic relationship if nobody was prepared to do anything to make that happen.

Me:      Yeah, it is obvious, but I think I slightly implied last time that the only non-sinful approach to the matter is to wait for a romantic relationship to just fall on you from the sky or something. What was it I said – “I do not need your so-called help to attempt to engineer things one way or the other”?

Her:     Uh-huh, that was it.

Me:      Yeah, that was potentially not brilliantly phrased. The major thing that I’m getting at there is that singleness is a valid and desirable option, which you refuse to acknowledge as such. And what I’m also suggesting on the side is that your particular manner of attempting to help engineer the alternative option is not very helpful – because, as we’ve just seen, it relies on one specific route to entering a romantic relationship, namely forming an attraction which might then be confessed. Ironic that the only route you can come up with is one to which I am not by nature at all readily disposed. The world calls what I’m like ‘demisexual’, apparently, but I personally consider the usefulness of labels in this sphere to be quite limited.8

Her:     All right, honey, so the situation is, I’m a bit rubbish but you don’t mind me sticking around as long as I behave myself?

Me:      Quite. Frankly, there are few facets of personality and thinking hanging about in my brain about which I’m any more positive than that. Count yourself privileged.

Her:     But if you don’t want me to help in the only way I know how, why exactly is it that you want me around?

Me:      You know that point you made earlier about Neoplatonism? That was a nice one. You can keep doing that sort of thing. You can even keep trying to persuade me that it would be a good idea to pursue a romantic relationship, if you like, but you’re probably going to have to come up with some practical advice as to how if you want anything to happen on that front.

Her:     You’re still on the fence about whether you want one, then.

Me:      Pros and cons, honey, pros and cons. It is still true that whether I ever have one or not, everything that happens will be for my good and God’s glory. He may spare me temptation or he may grant me the strength to resist it; either way, my duty is the same: to seek his kingdom first, to love him and my neighbour. At some stage, it may prove to be a good and prudent manifestation of that duty to pursue a romantic relationship.

Her:     “A good and prudent manifestation of that duty”? Dear me, honey, could you have phrased that sentiment any less romantically?

Me:      I doubt I could. Separated from you, I’m not sure I’ve got a properly romantic bone in my body – and you never know, my romantic side may come in useful at some point. Stick around, honey; I may have need of you yet.

Footnotes



1 I love this sketch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vm1AI3lp0Fo. The quotation doesn’t actually fit this post that well in terms of the actual sentiment expressed, but it’s so funny and I really wanted to stick it in my blog at some point.



2 You’re looking under ‘2017’ then ‘December’ in the box on the right.



3 You know, I sometimes forget just how much there is in Romans 8: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Romans+8&version=ESVUK.



4 Check out the paragraph beginning ‘the view that one ought to deny one’s lower desires’ in this article, for instance: https://www.britannica.com/topic/asceticism#ref150035.



5 This concern is addressed by Paul in 1 Timothy 4: https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Timothy+4&version=ESVUK. Note that he specifically identifies marriage as a good thing in this category, and the requirement of abstinence from marriage as a false teaching.



6 Here’s a really interesting article about a lady who created a board game based on arranged marriage and received some surprising reactions: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/stories-43376355. Some credit is owed here for my last point in the next paragraph, too.